If you’re looking for a racing shoe that combines bounce, stability, and premium details, the Tracksmith Eliot Racer genuinely surprised me. Going into this review, I honestly did not expect much from a racing shoe made by an apparel-first company—but after testing it, I can confidently say this shoe belongs in the same conversation as the biggest players in the super-shoe world.

This review reflects my personal experience after logging fast miles, workouts, and testing the shoe on multiple surfaces. The shoe was provided to me for review, but no one is paying me, and all opinions here are 100% my own.

What Is the Tracksmith Eliot Racer?

The Eliot Racer is Tracksmith’s first true super-shoe—a carbon-plated racing shoe designed for fast running from mile one to the finish line. Tracksmith already makes the original Eliot, which I’ve reviewed before, but that shoe leaned much more toward fashion and lifestyle for me.

This one? Completely different category.

I received the Eliot Racer right before the London Marathon, and based on my past experience with their daily trainer, I assumed this would be another “nice-looking but not race-ready” shoe. I didn’t race London in it—and after testing it, I’m honestly kicking myself. I had a great race day and think this shoe could have held its own (possibly even outperformed what I wore).

Tracksmith Eliot Racer: Key Specs

• Weight:

  • Men’s 9: 7.7 oz (218 g)

  • My women’s 8.5: 7.17 oz (203 g) — very light

• Drop: 7.5 mm

• Stack Height: 38 mm heel / 30.5 mm forefoot

• Foam: PEBAX midsole + TPU drop-in

• Plate: Full-length carbon plate

• Outsole: Durable rubber (extends to the lateral edge)

• Support: Neutral

• Price: $280

• Colors: Ivory/Gold (shown), Navy/Gold

On paper, it checks all the usual racing-shoe boxes: lightweight, max cushion, carbon plate, aggressive price point. But where it really stands out is in the design and construction details.

Upper: Premium Details Done Right

The upper is built from an engineered woven mesh—lightweight, breathable, and performance-oriented. What surprised me most is that it doesn’t sacrifice comfort for weight.

Here’s what stood out:

✔ The Tracksmith gold sash

This isn’t just aesthetic (though it is beautiful). The sash is made from a more structured material that adds midfoot stability. It gives the shoe shape and helps hold your foot in place—smart design.

✔ Suede-lined collar & tongue

This is one of my favorite touches. If you like hiding socks… or ditching socks completely, you won’t get hotspots or rubbing. It’s rare for a racing shoe to feel this smooth on the skin.

✔ Silicone-lined laces

Brilliant. They stay put, which means no re-tying mid-race and no worrying about loose flyaway laces. I wish every brand would copy this.

✔ Stable heel construction

The heel is structured without feeling rigid, so stepping into the shoe is easy even though the pull tab is more decorative than functional.

Overall, the upper strikes an impressive balance: lightweight, breathable, but still comfortable — which many racing shoes aren’t.

Midsole & Ride: Surprisingly Bouncy and Stable

The Eliot Racer uses a combination of:

• PEBAX foam (main midsole)

• A removable TPU drop-in insert

• A full-length carbon plate

This setup creates a ride that’s:

• bouncy without being sloppy,

• stable without being harsh,

• and responsive without feeling overly aggressive.

Honestly, it’s more forgiving than the Alphafly and less rigid than something like the Hoka Cielo X2. The rocker is noticeable but not extreme—just enough to roll you forward without throwing your cadence off.

The TPU drop-in

This is a genuinely cool feature. It fits snugly (no sliding), and inside it is Tracksmith’s message:

“Race day is sacred.”

It sounds like a small thing, but on race morning when nerves are high, little details like that can bring perspective.

And comfort-wise: no rubbing, no slipping, no blister potential. Impressive for a removable layer.

Outsole: Better Durability Than Expected

The rubber outsole wraps along the side of the midsole, which is amazing if you’re someone who chews up the outer edge of your shoes (I’m one of those people).

Many super-shoes expose bare foam along the sides—that’s the first place I destroy them. This added rubber might help the shoe cross the 100-mile mark in much better shape than its competitors.

Traction felt solid on roads and sidewalks. No sliding, no scraping sensations, and no surprise wear after my initial runs.

First Impressions

When I first unboxed the shoe, I’ll be honest: I picked the ivory gold because I assumed this would be a “tempo-and-outfit” type shoe. Something cute. Something I’d wear with Tracksmith apparel because, well… it matches everything.

But from the first run, I was shocked. It feels like a true racing shoe. Lightweight. Springy. Fast. It’s 100% capable of going to battle with the major carbon-plated marathon shoes.

On-the-Run Experience

Here’s what really stood out once I put miles on it:

✔ Energy return

The combination of foam + plate delivers real propulsion. It has a satisfying pop without feeling unstable.

✔ Leg and foot freshness

My feet didn’t feel fatigued after workouts, which tells me the cushioning + structure are working well.

✔ Stability

Unlike some racing shoes, this one doesn’t feel wobbly. That alone will make it appealing for a lot of runners.

✔ Comfort

No hotspots, no rubbing, even barefoot. For a racing shoe, that’s rare. If I had known it performed at this level, I would’ve raced London in it without hesitation.

Who Should Buy the Tracksmith Eliot Racer?

I’d recommend it for:

✔ Marathoners looking for a carbon-plated racing shoe
✔ Runners who want bounce without instability
✔ Anyone who prefers a less aggressive, more natural-feeling rocker
✔ Tracksmith fans who want a performance shoe that matches the vibe
✔ Runners who appreciate premium details and a stable ride

Final Verdict: Tracksmith Proves They Can Make a Real Racing Shoe

The Tracksmith Eliot Racer exceeded every expectation I had. It’s fast, bouncy, stable, beautifully designed, and detailed in a way most racing shoes simply aren’t. It holds its own against the big players and might even surpass them for runners who prefer a stable, centered feel underfoot.

I fully recommend it—and I’m genuinely excited to keep logging miles in it. I’ll be posting a 100-mile update once I get it fully broken in.

Related Stories